Funny Girl

Funny Girl is an American biographical musical about the real-life story of Fanny Brice who was a star on Vaudeville, Broadway, film and an early female comedian who shaped the industry for all that followed.

The show was originally produced on Broadway in 1964 and was later made into an award winning film in 1968.

The original Funny Girl show and movie should not be confused with the novel of the same name written by Nick Hornby that was published in 2014 and it is about a different person.

The 2022 Broadway show opened with Beanie Feldstein and Jane Lynch in the starring roles in March 2022.

Producers Replace Beanie Feldstein and Jane Lynch with Lea Michele and Tovah Feldshuh

Lea Michele returned to Broadway starring as Fanny Brice. The Glee star began performances on September 6, 2022. The standby, Julie Benko, will continue in the role for all Thursday performances.

Standby Benko Makes a Name For Herself in the Gap Between Feldstein's Departure and Michele's Debut

The little-known Julie Benko has been with the company since the revival opened in Match 2022 and has filled in for Feldstein during her bout of COVID-19, where she was out for 3 weeks. Benko then lead the show for a whole month during the gap between Feldstein's unanticipated early departure and Michele's debut.

Tovah Feldshuh also joined the production as Mrs. Brice replacing Jane Lynch on September 6. Lynch was previously announced to depart the production September 25, 2022 with Feldstein. Lynch left the production September 4 and never got to share the stage with her old Glee co-star Lea Michele. This scheduling problem may be by design as the two were never very fond of each other on the Glee TV set and although Broadway show producers would have loved to have a Glee reunion on Broadway, even if only for a few performances, it wasn't going to happen.

Embattled Lea Michele Faced Harsh Criticism From Film and Stage

Lea Michele has faced a lot of criticism from actors and staff who have shared the stage or screen with her over the years. Her oft-intense attitude for perfection may have come home to roost as outright diva arrogance and upset a lot of lesser people. Before she was canceled, the actress had always been a shoe-in for “Funny Girl” on Broadway.

It remains to be seen if Michele can overcome the naysayers long term with her appearance in the lead role in this behemoth of role in a monster of a Broadway show.

As Michele is taking over the role from Beanie Feldstein, there is no TONY Award potential, so the move could be a bunt-sacrifice, which may earn Michele some brownie points with all those that still think of her in unfavorable terms.

Lea Michele Receives Six Standing Ovations at Her First Performance of Funny Girl

Despite all the negative press and perceived acrimony for Lea Michele, the audience at Michele's first performance of Funny Girl on September 6th, 2022, gave her no less than six Standing Ovations. Four of those came prior to the intermission, proving that there is redemption for those that have been cancelled for past missteps.

Funny Girl on Broadway History:

Original Funny Girl Broadway Show Dates Back to 1964 and Barbra Streisand

The original 1964 Broadway show production was produced by Ray Stark and was written by Isobel Lennart. The music was written by Jule Styne and the lyrics came from Bob Merrill. Stark was able to provide first hand knowledge of the life experiences of Fanny Brice as he became her son-in-law when he married her daughter Frances in September 1940 and therefore he had over 24 years of shared experiences to add to the plot.

The show’s original title was My Man, but was changed at the last moment to better capture the critical responses to Brice’s story and to turn the focus back to Brice, when clearly Arnstein was a bit-player in her life story. Although critically acclaimed, the production failed to win any Tony awards despite being nominated for eight of the illustrious Awards at the ceremony in 1965.

Original Show Starred 'Then' Newcomer Barbra Streisand

The original 1964 Funny Girl Broadway show starred relative newcomer Barbra Streisand in the lead as Fanny Brice. Streisand was then fresh off her acclaimed role in I Can Get It For You Wholesale that ran for 300 performances in 1962.

The subsequent 1968 movie version of the show was a romanticized version of the Fanny Brice story. The movie ultimately became the breakout movie role for Streisand in Hollywood, much as the Broadway show was for her in New York. Streisand then went on to win the Oscar for best actress later that year.

Movie Romanticizes the True Nature of Nicky Arnstein

In the movie, Streisand starred opposite Omar Sharif as Nicky Arnstein, as her love interest. The director William Wyler decided to make her husband a far more exotic character than the real-life cad from New Jersey that she had actually married. This was also different to the version of Nicky Arnstein in the Broadway show.

Original West End Show Run in 1966 and West End Revivals

After the success of the show on Broadway, the show then had a West End run in 1966 and then toured across the world to much critical acclaim. A West End revival came in 2016 and a UK tour in 2017.

Idina Menzel Was Slated For Broadway Revival in 2022

This latest incarnation of the show was to feature Idina Menzel in the lead role and Michael Mayer directing, who is fresh off his critically acclaimed directorial debut at Little Shop of Horrors. Harvey Fierstein also had a hand in this production with a revised version of the book, that updates many of the funnier parts of the show and brings it back to the true reality of the Fanny Brice story.

Menzel Choice Faced Controversy and Dropped Out

Producers and Critics had complained that Idina Menzel had lost much of her luster after the debacle with her own Broadway show If/Then that barely crawled over the one-year finish line in its Broadway debut in 2015.

Pundits bemoaned that the whole pre-feminism story of Fanny Brice and Funny Girl would not be reshaped to fit in a post-feminism movement in a #MeToo world with Menzel in the lead role.

We now live in a world where women are doing it for themselves and they have very little sympathy for the pasts lack of activism, of which Brice may be guilty of and Menzel unable to retell.

Beanie Feldstein Debuted Role in Spring 2022

With the Idina Menzel controversy now well behind them, Funny Girl show producers decided to cast Beanie Feldstein in the lead role of Fanny Brice. Feldstein is known for mostly TV and movie work, but she did appear in Hello Dolly in 2017.

Feldstein is also pretty well connected in Broadway circles. Not only is she best friends with Ben Platt (with whom she went to high school) but Feldstein's brother is the slimmed-down movie actor and director Jonah Hill.

Beanie Feldstein and Jane Lynch Were to Depart the Show on Sept. 25, 2022

Both stars were scheduled to depart the show on Sept. 25, 2022. This was due to Feldstein's inability to stay healthy and Lynch who is fed up with Feldstein's absences. The male leads, Ramin Karimloo and Jared Grimes, were to remain with the show. Replacement casting for Feldstein and Lynch had not been announced, and producers made a lot of calls because if a suitable replacement was not found, the show would have closed.

The fiasco of this show will be a dark cloud for Feldstein, and will affect any future Broadway musical in which she intends to star. Potential replacements for the lead roles include Julie Benko, Sarah Silverman and Lea Michele.

Beanie Feldstein Departed the Show Even Sooner Than Planned

Feldstein shocked social media by announcing she’s quitting the revival of Broadway’s Funny Girl even sooner than expected. Her exit comes amid cryptic reports of the show going in a “different direction.” The actress posted the message to her disappointed fans on Instagram, saying she’ll be leaving July 31, 2022 instead of her original early departure date of Sept. 25, 2022. Now the producers were in trouble.